Discover
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen Menu
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
Member of the Tribe
$18.99Peter Shelsky
$20.49The Fancy Pants
$24.49Lewis' Maine Style Lobster Roll
$25.99Brooklyn Native
$20.99The Great Gatsby
$19.99Shelsky's Pastrami (Pastrami Smoked Salmon)
$20.99Brooklyn Transplant
$20.49El Vincente
$23.49The Spicy Red, Spicy White or Spicy Blue
$17.49The Holy Mackerel
$14.99The Whitefish Club
$17.49The Tribute
$22.99The Fishless
$12.49Spicy Shrimp Roll
$16.49The Newhouse
$20.49The Turboff
$20.99The Clementine
$20.49Osetra's Momma
$21.49The Tuna Super Spicy Funk
$17.99Trout & About
$19.75Transmontanus
$100.00Osetra Caviar
$166.00Kaluga Imperial Caviar
$191.00Kaluga Caviar
$151.00Golden Osetra Caviar
$241.00Vermont Dairy Creme Fraiche
$10.99Smoked Trout Roe
$31.99French Trout Roe
$26.99Mother of Pearl Spoon
$8.9916 Count Mini Bilinis
$12.99Keta Salmon Roe
$20.99
Caviar and Roe
Salad Spread Sandwiches
Egg Salad with Cornichons On a Bread
$12.99Chicken Salad with Pecans, Grapes & Celery On a Bread
$13.99Pickled Herring Salad On a Bread
$13.99Seriously Great Tuna Salad On a Bread
$13.99Baked Salmon Salad On a Bread
$16.49Smoked Whitefish Salad with Cucumber & Celery On a Bread
$16.49Smoked Bluefish Salad with Hazelnuts, Oranges & Fennel On a Bread
$16.00Chopped Chicken Liver On Bread
$15.99Bagel with Butter
$4.49Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
$6.99Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
$7.49Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese
$9.49Bagel with Veggy Cream Cheese
$9.49Bagel with Horseradish Cream Cheese
$8.99Bagel with Scallion Vegan Cream Cheese (Stockeld Original Dairy Free)
$8.99Bagel with Chili Crisp Cream Cheese
$9.49Bagel with Vegan Cream Cheese (Sockeld Original Dairy Free)
$8.49Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese copy
$9.49 Sandwich with a Schmear/ Butter
Classic Delicatessen Sandwiches
Lewis'knish Bomb
$22.99Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$27.99Shelsky's Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
$26.99Shelsky's Reuben Sandwich
$28.99Corned Tongue Sandwich
$23.99Shelskys Roast Beef Roll
$19.99Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich
$20.99Plain Bagel
$2.00Everything Bagel
$2.00Sesame Bagel
$2.00Poppyseed Bagel
$2.00Egg Bagel
$2.00Onion Bagel
$2.00Garlic Bagel
$2.00Pumpernickel Bagel
$2.00Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
$2.00Wholewheat Plain Bagel
$2.00Wholewheat Everything Bagel
$2.00Onion Bialy
$2.00Garlic Poppy Bialy
$2.00Pretzel bagel
$3.50Sichuan Peppercorn Bagel
$3.50Gluten Free Plain Bagel
$4.99Gluten Free Everything Bagel
$4.99Salt Bagel
$2.00Gluten Free Sesame Bagel
$4.99 Shelsky's Bagels
Cold Smoked & Cured Fish
1/4 Lb Tsar's Cut Balik Salmon
$26.74Double Cured Irish Salmon
$16.49Eastern Gaspe Nova
$15.49Mild Scottish Salmon
$17.49New Brunswick Salmon
$13.49Homemade Gravlax
$15.99David Burke Pastrami Salmon
$16.49Wild Alaskan Sable
$22.99Salty Belly Lox
$15.49Ora King Salmon (Organic & Sustainable)
$17.49Bering Cisco
$39.99Whole Smoked Red Trout
$35.00Wild King Salmon Bacon
$24.24Fatty Kippered Salmon
$16.74Door County, WI Whole Whitefish
$41.99Peppered Hot Smoked Salmon
$23.48Fancy Lake Sturgeon
$23.74Hot Smoked Bluefish
$23.98Samaki Smoked Trout Fillets
$16.99Peppered Hot Smoked Bluefish
$23.98smoked Peppered Mackerel
$23.99 Hot Smoked & Kippered Fish
Herring
House Pickled Herring
$4.50Matjes Herring
$6.25Mustard Dill Herring
$4.75Roll Mops with Sour Pickles
$4.50Roll Mops with Pickled Onions
$4.50Schmaltz Herring
$6.00Braided Challah
$10.99Plain Rye Bread
$5.00Seeded Rye Bread
$5.00Pumpernickel Rye Bread
$5.00Round Onion Rolls
$5.00 Baked Breads
House Cream Cheese
1/2 Lb Plain Cream Cheese
$8.991/2 Lb Scallion Cream Cheese
$9.491/2 Lb Vegetable Cream Cheese
$9.991/2 Lb Vegan Scallion Cream Cheese (Stockeld Dairy Free)
$10.991/2 Lb Horseradish Cream Cheese
$13.491/2 Lb Lox Cream Cheese
$12.991/2 Lb Chili Crisp Cream Cheese
$10.991/2 Lb Vegan Cream Cheese (Stockeld Original Dairy Free)
$10.49Matzo Ball Soup
$17.491/2 Lb Bluefish Salad
$21.251/2 Lb Pickled Herring Salad
$11.381/2 Lb Whitefish Salad
$19.981/2 Lb Lobster Salad with Tarragon
$23.991/2 Lb Cucumber Salad
$8.991/2 Lb Citrus Roasted Beet Salad
$8.991/2 Lb Egg Salad with Cornichons
$8.991/2 Lb House Pickled Lox
$28.991/2 Lb Chicken Salad
$12.491/2 Lb Baked Salmon Salad
$19.981/2 Lb Seriously Great Tuna Salad
$13.491/2 Lb Chopped Liver
$10.491/2 Lb Rice Pudding
$5.991/2 Lb Spicy Shrimp Salad
$15.991/2 Lb Macaroni Salad
$5.991/2 Lb Potato Salad
$5.991/2 Lb Coleslaw
$5.991/2 Lb Health Salad
$6.49Quart of Pickled Tomatoes
$9.50Quart of Sour Pickles
$9.50Quart of Half Sour Pickles
$9.50Bag of 2 Pickles
$3.50 Soups, Salads & Spreads
Delicatessen Meats
1/2 Lb Homemade Roast Beef
$18.491/2 Lb Classic Delicatessen Pastrami
$19.651/2 Lb Classic Delicatessen Corned Beef
$19.131/2 Lb Homemade Pickled Beef Tongue
$19.651/2 Lb Roast Turkey
$19.13Potato Latke
$4.49Sweet Potato Latkes
$4.49One Dozen Traditional Potato Latkes
$48.99Grandma Yetta's Applesauce
$10.99Dozen Gluten-Free Latkes
$67.99Dozen Sweet Potato & Celeriac Latkes
$48.99 Latkes and Accoutrerment
Knishes
Fried Square Knish
$5.49Baked Broccoli Knish
$5.99Baked Kasha Knish
$5.99Baked Potato Knish
$5.99Laoganma Spicy Chili Crisp
$6.99Auria's Hot Chilli Sambal
$15.99Auria's Pandan Kaya
$15.99Wasabi Masago Tobiko
$11.99Ortiz Boquerones Anchovies
$13.49Hudson Valley Harvest Raw Local Honey
$10.25Hartley's Strawberry Jam
$7.99Ines Rosales Original with Anise
$6.99Fox's U-Bet Vanilla Flavored Syrup
$7.99Kewpie Japanese Mayonnaise
$10.33Fox's U-Bet Chocolate Flavored Syrup
$7.99Sarson's Malt Vinegar
$3.99Uncle Jerry's Extra Dark Pretzels
$6.99Uncle Jerry's Pretzels "Specials"
$6.99Tate's and Lyle's Dessert Syrup
$5.25HP Sauce
$5.89 Imports Selections
Chips
Large Torres Black Truffle Chips
$8.29Small Torres Black Truffle Chips
$5.99Large Torres Mediterranean Salt
$7.99Small Torres Mediterranean Herbs Chips
$5.99Small Torres Mediterranean Salt Chips
$5.99Large Sal de Ibiza White Truffle Chips
$7.99Large Torres Foie Gras Chip
$8.29Large Torres Cured Cheese Chip
$6.50Small Sal De Ibiza White Truffle Chips
$5.99Bissli BBQ
$1.99Bissli Falafel
$1.99Fine Cheese Co. Gluten-Free Water Crackers
$6.99Fine Cheese Co Water Crackers
$4.99Carr's Original Table Water Cracker
$5.68Carr's Cracked Pepper Table Water Cracker
$5.68Carr's Poppy & Sesame Thin Savory Crackers
$5.68Firehook Sea Salt Baked Crackers
$9.50Firehook "Mini" Everything Baked Crackers
$7.75Firehook "Mini" Sea Salt Cracker
$7.75Norwegian Baked Knekkebrd Classic
$11.99Norwegian Baked Knekkebrd Sea Salt Flakes
$11.99Mcvitite's Digestives Original
$4.99Mcvitie's Digestives Dark Chocolate
$5.99Norwegian Baked Knekkebrd Rosemary & Lemon
$11.99Norwegian Baked Knekkebrd Chili & Coriander
$11.99 Cookies and Crackers
Seed and Mill Halvah
1/2 Lb Marble Halvah
$19.991/2 Lb Nougat Halvah
$19.991/2 Lb Crunch Peanut Butter Halvah
$19.991 lb Granola From Another Mother
$20.991/2 LB - Granola From Another Mother
$10.49 Granola From Another Mother
Shelsky's Appetizing and Delicatessen Gift Cards
Shelsky's $15 Gift Card
$15.00Shelsky's $25 Gift Card
$25.00Shelsky's $50 Gift Card
$50.00Shelsky's $75 Gift Card
$75.00Shelsky's $100 Gift Card
$100.00Shelsky's $150 Gift Card
$150.00Shelsky's $200 Gift Card
$200.00Chocolate Lingonberry Rugelach 1/2 Lb
$10.99Raspberry Walnut Rugelach 1/2 Lb
$10.99Apricot Walnut Rugelach 1/2 Lb
$10.99Clementine Ginger Rugelach 1/2 Lb
$10.99Chocolate Babka
$23.00One Black and White Cookie
$2.50Two Black and Whites Cookies
$4.00 Baked Sweets
Candy
SML Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs
$2.50Joyva Jelly Rings Box
$9.99Joyva Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Twist
$9.99LRG Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs
$3.50Bamba Peanut Puff with Hazelnut Filling
$3.00Joyva King Size Chocolate Cover Halvah
$3.99Nestle Lion Choco Bar
$2.49Joyva Marble Halvah Bar
$1.99Joyva Vanilla Halva Bar
$1.99Joray Fruit Rolls
$1.75Joyva Chocolate Cover Halvah
$1.99Lion White Bar
$3.49Boost Bar
$1.99Cadbury Dairy Milk Fruit & Nut
$1.50Cadbury Dairy Milk Original
$1.50Cadbury Dairy Milk Whole Nut
$1.5012oz Ashlawn Farm Hot Drip Coffee
$4.0016oz Ashlawn Farm Hot Drip Coffee
$5.0016 Oz Ashlawn Farm Iced Cold Brew
$5.50Coffee Villa Borghesi (12 Oz Bag)
$17.99Ashlawn Farm Coffee Box
$37.00 Ashlawn Farm Coffee
Hot Teas
Genmaicha Yama (Classic Green Tea)
$3.00Th Du Hammam (Vert Green Tea)
$3.00La Menthe (Mint Green Tea)
$3.00Darjeeling Margaret's Hope (Black Tea)
$3.00Blue of London (Earl Grey)
$2.00Rooibos Du Hammam (Smoked Red Tea)
$3.0012 Oz Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
$1.5012 Oz Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
$1.5012 Oz Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
$1.5012 Oz Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry
$1.5012 Oz Dr. Brown's Ginger Ale
$1.5012 Oz Dr. Brown's Root Beer
$1.5016.9 Oz Poland Spring Water
$1.5012 Oz Diet Coke Can
$1.5012 Oz Scheweppes Ginger Ale
$1.2512 Oz Topo-Chico Sparkling Mineral Water
$2.5012 Oz Mexican Coke Glass Bottle
$3.7512 Oz Canada Dry Seltzer Can
$1.25Lagunitas Hops Refresher
$3.00United Sodas of America- White Grape Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Pear Elderflower Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Young Mango Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Blackberry Jam Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Sour Blueberry Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Strawberry Basil Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Lemon Verbena Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Cheery Pop Flavor
$2.99United Sodas of America- Orange Nectarine Flavor
$2.99 Cold Soda & Beverages
Fever-Tree Soda/ Tonic
Fever-Tree Elderflower Tonic Water
$2.00Fever-Tree Premium Indian Tonic Water
$2.00Fever-Tree Premium Club Soda
$2.00Egg Sandwich
$7.00Bacon & Egg Sandwich
$9.99Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$8.99BLT
$9.49Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$10.99Sausage, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$10.99Sausage & Egg Sandwich
$9.99Ham & Egg Sandwich
$9.99Ham, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$9.99Jersey Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich
$11.49Jersey Pork Roll Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$12.49Chorizo & Egg Sandwich
$11.99Chorizo, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$12.49Cream Cheese and Bacon Sandwich
$9.49Scrapple, Egg, Cheddar & Maple Syrup
$9.99Pastrami & Egg Sandwich
$11.99Chopped Cheese Sandwich
$15.49Impossible Chopped Cheese
$18.49Pastrami, Egg & Cheese Sandwich
$13.49